Alternative to Bose
September 30, 2003
Hi Wes,
I am currently in the market for a surround speaker system.
My question is about the Bose AM10. I really like the sound, but a lot of reviews I have
read have said the bass is weak and the speakers are overpriced. Can you suggest some
speaker systems that compare with the Bose? I have heard good things about Axiom
(including at this website), but I don't know which models are comparable to the AM10s.
John
I do prefer Axiom's speakers to Bose's myself, but that
does not invalidate your appreciation of the Bose AM10. What a lot of audiophiles manage
to overlook in their anti-Bose tirades is that Bose owners repeatedly list themselves as
"extremely happy" with their speakers.
Is that because Bose consumers "don't know any
better," as many of the company's critics claim? I think that's a condescending,
simplistic answer. Bose makes its systems easy to set up, and systems like the AM10 manage
to put out a lot of sound for the space they take up -- factors that people who like big,
complicated loudspeakers tend to undervalue.
I'm a big advocate of the philosophy that listening to
music and watching movies are supposed to add happiness to your life, not add tension and
uncertainty. If you like the AM10s and think they're worth the money Bose asks for them,
then they are -- no argument from me or any other "expert" could prove
otherwise.
On the other hand, I loved the Axiom
Epic Grand Master system and would recommend you listen to it, too....Wes Phillips
Speaker-terminal issue
September 25, 2003
Dear Wes,
I have recently invested a truck-load of money in a Denon
AVC-A1SR amp plus A1 DVD player (Denon 580 and 9000 in the US). They are connected to PSB
Stratus-series speakers. The interconnects and speaker cables are all Monster Cable M
series. The speaker terminals at the rear of the amp seem to be built only for bare wire,
however. The ends of the Monster biwire cable have interlocks that can accommodate bananas
or spades but not bare wires. At the rear of the amp there are little black square plastic
bits around the speaker terminals that prevent spades, and the centers of the terminals
are blocked so no bananas can fit. Is there any way of connecting bananas or spades
without doing any damage? Please let me know.
Lalit
Most binding posts have -- wait a minute, are we alone?
[Furtive glance over the shoulder] OK, nobody here but us audiophiles.
As I was saying, most binding posts with those plugs in the
center of the post are a nudge-nudge-wink-wink response to safety legislation. Those
plastic plugs can generally be pried out of the binding posts, leaving you with a socket
that accepts a banana.
Now, I don't recommend you do this. I merely report the
fact that it can be done.
All the best....Wes Phillips
Screen considerations
September 22, 2003
Wes,
I am purchasing a projector rated at 2200 ANSI lumens and
considering the Stewart
GreyHawk screen because another reviewer recommended that combination. I was wondering
if there's a need for the GreyHawk in order to bring out the blacks. My home-theater room
is a dedicated room and does not have any light coming in. You also mention that this
screen was designed for DLP projectors and mine is an LCD. Will that make a difference?
Bill
The GreyHawk should do just fine with an LCD projector
putting out 2200 ANSI lumens, especially for dark scenes. On the other hand, some viewers
prefer more overall brightness, even if they lose out on detail and black level. In your
dedicated room, with no ambient light, you could certainly get by with higher-gain screen,
but what you gain in brilliance, you'll pay for in shadow detail.
I watch a lot of B&W films and murky nourish thrillers,
so my decision is obvious, but your preferred genre of film might be very different -- and
so might your choice of screen....Wes Phillips
DVI
September 16, 2003
Wes,
I have an RPTV with a DVI input. The new crop of DVD
players have DVI outputs. Will there be an improvement using this connection on my RPTV
compared to component video?
Jim
The answer is maybe. Does that help?
No, of course it doesn't. It's actually a pretty
complicated subject -- for now.
It all depends on a number of factors. For example, is your
RPTV digital or analog? If it's digital, DVI might offer a noticeable improvement over
component input. But then you have to ask whether or not your cable box or tuner outputs
DVI -- do you want to have to use component and DVI inputs? Of course, if you're using an
HDTV source, as well as a DVD player that outputs high-rez on DVI, you might not have to
make that choice.
And then there's the issue of which high-rez display your
DVD player and RPTV-player support. I've heard reports that 480p on DVI isn't noticeably
superior to component input, but 720p -- at least, from what I've seen -- is startlingly
crisper.
Of course, this would be so much simpler if we had some
form of standardization, but we've been promised that for a long time and there's still no
resolution in sight....Wes Phillips
More expensive cables worth it?
September 10, 2003
Wes,
I was wondering what your opinion on Monster Cable is. Does
Monster Cable make much of a difference compared to normal brands, and is it worth the
cost? I was looking for two digital coaxial cables the other day and came across the
Monsters. They were $50 each for 6' of cable. It seemed pretty expensive, so I got a
couple of more reasonably priced off-brand coax cables for $10 each. They sound fine, but
then again I haven't heard it on the Monsters.
Ryu
By "Monster Cable," I assume you are asking
about the whole category of specialty audio/video cables and not specifically the products
manufactured by Monster Cable the company. This is a pretty controversial subject and the
answer depends on your system, your requirements, and your budget.
The quality of cables and of the connectors they utilize
can have an impact on the sound of your system and audiophiles are quite vocal about
whether those differences are profound or simply subtle (some would claim illusory).
I've posted several reviews of audio cables on www.onhifi.com that discuss some of the
differences between cables.
In the realm of coaxial digital cables, the differences
tend to be less pronounced, in my opinion. That's assuming the connectors are the right
impedance (75 ohm) for the digital signal, which not all are.
So the short answer to your question is that your $10
S/PDIF digital cables are probably just fine -- and, the important thing is that you like
the way they sound....Wes Phillips
7.1?
September 2, 2003
Hi Wes,
Thank you for a lucid intro into
surround theory. But no matter how much you explain, I will always have more
questions.
Specifically, if I were to have a 7.1 system (front,
center, right, side left, side right, rear left, rear right), would I be getting seven
discrete channels of sound? To the point, are the rear left and right separate
information? I mean, if 6.1 already has a rear speaker, then 7.1 splitting that channel to
two speakers hardly sounds like it would be an improvement. Thank you for your time, and
patience.
Bob
It all depends on how you define discrete. In one sense,
you will be getting seven channels of information, with each channel receiving its own
separate amplified signal. However, as you suspect, the two rear channels are identical.
You say that it "hardly sounds like it would be an improvement," but that may be
missing the point of diffusion. (On the other hand, maybe not -- there's no real consensus
on this.)
In a movie theater, the same signal is sent to entire banks
of loudspeakers -- the whole point of this is to remove the specificity of the sonic
image, to kind of mush it up to sound bigger. This is the theory behind 7.1 -- to remove
that pinpoint imaging of the single center channel and give the rear-channel sound more
spaciousness.
Of course, that's the theory. It might even be true in
really large home theaters, but in small to mid-sized rooms, those rear channels are going
to be so close together that the mono summed image is going to sound pretty specific; I
suspect it will be functionally equivalent to a single rear channel.
So, the natural question is, why buy a 7.1 receiver? The
answer depends on your room size, the receiver's feature set, and, of course, price. When
calculating price, by the way, don't forget to include the cost of the extra
loudspeaker....Wes Phillips
|